21 votes
Accepted

Does Writing.SE accept critique requests?

TL;DR: Critique questions are off-topic, because they will be helpful only to you and the text you post. Questions using your writing to illustrate a question, however, are on-topic. The main problem ...
user avatar
12 votes
Accepted

Are there some hidden rules I am not aware of that would explain the relatively high amount of downvotes on new posts lately?

SE generally allows people to use their votes as they see fit, even if a lot of them are downvotes. However, targeted voting (in either direction) is a violation of the rules, because votes are ...
user avatar
12 votes
Accepted

Can I ask people about the inconsistency of the tone?

We don't do critiques Posting an exert of your writing and asking for feedback or help fixing it will be closed as off topic. We also don't do requests for rephrasing or problem solving specific ...
user avatar
  • 4,068
11 votes

Does Writing.SE accept critique requests?

I might just be rephrasing Monica in other words, but here's my take. I think critique questions are very poor in Stack Exchange's Q&A format. We've been trying different variations and ...
user avatar
  • 28k
10 votes

On topic: "How do I teach [whatever writing concept]?"

Such questions are on-topic. For example there has been the meta discussion Are questions about teaching writing on-topic?. Not much "discussion", but no single downvote on the question and answer. ...
user avatar
  • 5,586
9 votes
Accepted

Closing ancient questions

If a question is off topic, then vote to close with an appropriate close reason. It doesn't really matter if it's old or new. Site standards do change over time, and whether a question is open or ...
user avatar
  • 3,744
8 votes

Are questions about general plot solutions on-topic?

As another answer says, the line isn't as clear as we might like it to be. I think you've done a good job of asking a plotting-technique question as opposed to a plot question. Stories where heroes ...
user avatar
7 votes
Accepted

What is ok in questions about writing comics?

I'd be fine with it. You are still crafting a story, creating characters and relationships, unfolding a plot, even with imagery added to words. It's not about film-making, which is an entirely ...
user avatar
7 votes

Do the on topic rules fit non-fiction, particularly technical writing?

Parsimony is desirable when defining a site's topic. If we cannot parsimoniously include technical writing questions which we are justified in thinking should be on-topic, the rules we are using to ...
user avatar
7 votes
Accepted

Why are examples of writing and critiques off topic again?

Aric's answer here covers current policy well. And Mark's answer makes a very good point about reusability. As for the history - Writing critiques have been off-topic for quite some time here. Part of ...
user avatar
7 votes

What's our stance on terminology questions?

We have already accepted terminology questions and have 43 questions with the tag. Many of these are not actually about writing terminology, but a significant number are. This doesn't mean that we ...
user avatar
  • 2,222
7 votes

Are there some hidden rules I am not aware of that would explain the relatively high amount of downvotes on new posts lately?

I've seen this before on other SE sites. So when I started being active here I assumed it was just common here as well. As you observed, there seems to be no logical reasoning behind it. Sure if a ...
user avatar
  • 4,401
7 votes
Accepted

Are questions about MLA formatting on-topic?

Sure. We even have a tag with 80 questions in it. See mla
user avatar
  • 4,401
7 votes

Song Lyrics - On topic?

If questions are specifically about lyrics and not music, they're fine. Questions purely about music can be asked on Music|SE. However, songs aren't just music and lyrics; there's a lot of interplay ...
user avatar
6 votes

Is asking how to describe something on topic?

"How should I describe (THING)" is off-topic, as an "asking what to write" question. Context isn't the issue here; it's the type of question being asked, and the type of answers that question is ...
user avatar
  • 28k
6 votes

Are there some hidden rules I am not aware of that would explain the relatively high amount of downvotes on new posts lately?

Thanks for bringing this up. I've seen another odd pattern where I'll be on SE and I see several downvotes for different posts of mine come in a fairly short time. Like 3 in 5 minutes. Some of the ...
user avatar
6 votes

New reviewer, looking for clarification about what appears to be a request to critique

It's not the strongest question out there, and it's pretty borderline in the sense of asking for a critique, but it's a writing question and is more or less on topic. We're not as stringent about ...
user avatar
5 votes
Accepted

Are "How Could" questions on topic?

How could a criminal forget a crime? How can I arrange a murder without tipping off the murder that they are the criminal? I agree that this question isn't yet the strongest it could be. In ...
user avatar
5 votes

Please vote! What should we do with questions that are no longer on-topic?

Make a community effort. Let's have a concentrated push to clean up the site and make it what we want to be. As a coordinated community event, we'll go back and try to close questions which violate ...
user avatar
  • 28k
5 votes
Accepted

Are "how can I hide information" questions on topic?

Yes, such questions are on-topic For example you could look at some questions that go in similar direction, such as: How to hide something in plain sight (and keep it hidden)? How to make the ...
user avatar
  • 5,586
5 votes
Accepted

Topicality of question on how to give feedback

Questions about how to review or critique are on-topic. (Editing is on-topic, and this is related.) Your question as proposed feels too broad, but you could narrow it down by including: type of ...
user avatar
5 votes

Are there some hidden rules I am not aware of that would explain the relatively high amount of downvotes on new posts lately?

I've reviewed the voting patterns on Writing lately and I have seen some patterns: (The site analytics page is available to 5k users on beta sites.) Notice that nearly all the voting on the site is ...
user avatar
5 votes

Would this question be acceptable for Writing, or is it better suited on e.g. Worldbuilding?

Very broadly speaking: Worldbuilding is for questions about the setting in which your story is set, but not the story itself Writing is for questions on how to get your story or point across (...
user avatar
  • 3,744
4 votes
Accepted

Are questions about finding specific books on topic?

There's now a Literature Stack Exchange site where you can ask this kind of question (or, for that matter, other general questions about literature, books, publication process, and a wide variety of ...
user avatar
4 votes

Is my question on an unusual editing technique on-topic?

About Pre-Posting to Meta It isn't recommended practice to post an entire question on Meta as "screening" for the main site. Just as we don't want an off-topic question on the main site, so we don't ...
user avatar
  • 28k
4 votes
Accepted

Are questions about analyzing a non-literature writing on-topic?

From the help center: On the other hand, these kinds of questions aren't allowed here: Questions seeking to interpret or analyze an existing work, although there are exceptions if is being applied ...
user avatar

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible