1

When doing an off topic close the only options are Meta and ELU. it would be nice to add ELL, Stack Overflow and Academia.

2

Stack Exchange generally resists requests to add to this list (ELU was already an exception for us). However, if there's data to support a request, we can ask for this.

The best way to approach a proposal to add to the migration list is to post a meta question for one specific site and include links to questions that either were or should have been migrated there. If we've only ever migrated a dozen questions to Site X they're going to tell us to do that manually, but if we're sending questions to certain sites on a fairly regular basis or in volume, that's different.

My gut feeling is that ELL could be a candidate, Stack Overflow isn't, and I don't know about Academia but I'm leaning against. Rather than any of us guessing, though, let's look at data.

  • This morning there was a question in the close vote que that should be migrated to SO. I spent less than 10 minutes looking at migration questions here, and found at least two meta questions talking about migrating technical questions to SO. They all thought that the other two sites would be more common. Besides they can't say yes if we don't ask. – hildred Jan 28 '15 at 20:10
  • 2
    Ah, let me clear up some possible confusion: moderators can migrate a question anywhere, so if you think a question belongs on SO or Academia or wherever, use a custom flag to request it. It's helpful to also leave a comment about that if you can. We're only talking here about the options that are offered in the "belongs on another site" close dialogue. – Monica Cellio Jan 28 '15 at 21:16
  • 2
    Perhaps this indicates that the interface needs to be changed. I.e., provide an "Other" option for belongs elsewhere close reason, which could then be presented for moderator attention. (It might be convenient if such provided to the moderator information about the voter's qualification for recommending the migration [e.g., rep. on recommended site, perhaps also considering vote count, question view count, and visit days for active lurkers, even "read on-topic help page" might be useful information].) Flagging for moderator attention is not an obvious choice. – Paul A. Clayton Feb 3 '15 at 0:17

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .