8

Going through the first post que, I am noticing today for the first time spam trying to sell homework essays. Some is so bad as to have multiple reasons for deletion. Ok fine, I can stomp on that easy. The hard ones are answer attempts which are decent, with a sales link at the end. So far on these, I have been removing the link, and treating it like any other answer. Is this the right thing to do or do we want to stomp these harder?

The specific fingerprint I am seeing is a keyword repeted in the following three places: the username, the hostname from the link, and somewhere else in a changed form.

8

The general advice from SE is to just flag spam as spam. This is especially true if the post if from a new, 1-rep user with no non-spam posts -- chances are it really is a spammer. Flagging as spam helps to expedite the removal of the post and also provides feedback to certain automated spam-prevention systems.

But in your case you found answers that seemed ok except for the spam link, and everybody was new and 1-rep at some time so maybe these are reasonable users who need a little guidance. Thank you for trying to help by preserving the possibly-useful parts of the content instead of just blowing it all away. In the two specific cases that I noticed, though, I ended up deleting the posts anyway, and here's why:

It turned out that the non-spam parts of the posts were plagiarized. One seems to be copied all over the net (the top five or six Google results were other copies of that exact text). How did I find the plagiarism? I pasted the first paragraph of the answer into Google to see what would turn up.

Tacking spam onto an otherwise-ok post seems to be a newer spammer tactic. It also seems that they don't feel obligated to actually write that otherwise-ok post themselves.

So when you see something like this, please either just flag as spam (it is, after all) or check for plagiarism before making a saving edit. If the post does seem to be the poster's own work, and if it's actually an answer per the Help Center, then editing out the spam and leaving a comment explaining why seems like a reasonable response. Otherwise, best to leave the post as-is and flag.

For people who can see deleted posts, here are the two cases that prompted this post:

(Ooh, consecutive user numbers -- just noticed that. Spam sometimes comes in waves like that.)

  • 5
    Generally it's best to assume good faith when people toss a link into their answer. But when someone plagiarizes the rest of their answer on a site for writers, I think there's plenty of evidence that they did not act in good faith. Good find. – Jon Ericson Jan 23 '15 at 18:44
  • I found one of those too and did exactly what @hildred did: prune the spam, leave the answer. Well done you to research the plagiarism! – Lauren Ipsum Jan 25 '15 at 15:54

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .