7

Using the [programming] tag is discouraged on stackoverflow.

Using the [apple] tag is discouraged on apple.se.

Using the [english] tag is discouraged on english.se.

For the above cases, the theory is that each particular tag should apply to every question on the site—that is, if there's a question where it doesn't apply, that question probably isn't a good fit for the site in general.

In the spirit of the above, is there a reason for the [writing] tag here?

11

It seems like, if we follow the logic as you've laid it out, there is no reason for the [writing] tag to be used here. That seems logical to me, if it's on this site is be default about writing.

1

I would tend to agree, as well. Every question on here is about writing in some way, shape, or form. It's too tempting for people to just select "Writing" as a tag and move on - which is incredibly unhelpful. I would like to see more specific tags used.

-2

Just to play Devil's Advocate, I can see one use of the tag.

New users cannot create new tags, but also cannot post a question unless it has at least one tag. The writing tag could be a useful placeholder until a higher-rep user comes along and re-tags the question with something more relevant and specific.

Not that I necessarily agree with this, but it's good to develop all sides of the argument.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .