In this question, I expressed the opinion that there are few hard and fast rules to identifying genre. You can choose the genre you want to claim for your story based on the aspects of the story you consider to be the most important.
This was the accepted answer, but the poster then went on to ask another "What Genre is This" question.
Personally, I feel that this type of question is not useful and should be closed.
- It's subjective. There are no concrete definitions of genre.
- It adds little value to the site, as it is highly specific to the original poster's story and unlikely to help anyone else decide what genre their story is. This only encourages a proliferation of these questions, identical except for the specific story.
What does everyone else think? Close as subjective/argumentative, or do these questions have value?